Showing posts with label Carla Kelly. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Carla Kelly. Show all posts

Friday, November 9, 2012

Lists and Canons and Other Things


It’s not even mid-November and Publishers Weekly has already announced their top five romances of 2012. I have read four of the five and enjoyed them all, but I was surprised to see Mrs. Drew Plays Her Hand on the list. Don’t misunderstand. It’s a wonderful book, one that has been on my top 100 romance novels list since I first compiled it a dozen years ago. But it was first published in 1994 and Cedar Fort’s 2012 reissue is not even the first time it has been reissued. I’d vote for Mrs. Drew Plays Her Hand as a classic romance, but I would not include it in my Best of 2012 list.

The question of which romance novels merit the label “classic” is another topic that usually evokes lively discussion. A more academic approach is to consider what novels belong in the canon of romance fiction. As romance scholar Jonathan A. Allan noted in a recent Teach Me Tonight post, there is no list of the "central texts of romance fiction that all scholars of popular romance should have read." Even if there were such a list, I wonder if romance readers would agree with scholars’ choice of “central texts.”

Several years ago, in one of those serendipitous moments that make me love research, I came across an article in which librarians knowledgeable about the romance genre generally and also fans of a particular subgenre selected five books that in their opinion “highlighted the features of that subgenre.”  I am an inveterate maker of lists myself, and I am always intrigued by other people’s lists. Librarians listing romances had particular appeal since before I became active in online romance-reading communities I had never encountered a librarian who admitted reading romance. Because these lists serve as recommendations for other librarians interested in building their libraries’ romance collections, these romances might be considered the “classics” in the various subgenres.

Traditional Regency
1.     Hern, Candice. A Garden Folly. New York: Signet, 1997
2.     Kelly, Carla. Mrs. Drew Plays Her Hand. New York: New American Library, 2003
3.     Lane, Allison. The Rake's Rainbow. New York: New American Library, 1996
4.     Metzger, Barbara. A Debt to Delia. New American Library, 2002
5.     Richardson, Evelyn. Lady Alex's Gamble. New American Library, 1995

Historical
1.     Beverley, Jo. Forbidden Magic. New York: New American Library, 2005
2.     Putney, Mary Jo. The Wild Child. New York: Ballantine Books, 2000
3.     Wiggs, Susan. The Lightkeeper. New York: Mira, 2002
4.     Quinn, Julia. The Duke and I. New York: Avon Books, 2000
5.     Schone, Robin. Scandalous Lovers. New York: Kensington, 2007

Contemporary
1.     Crusie, Jennifer. Bet Me. New York: St. Martin's Pr., 2004
2.     Gibson, Rachel. See Jane Score. New York: Avon, 2003
3.     Greene, Jennifer Blame It on Cupid. New York: HQN Books, 2007
4.     Phillips, Susan Elizabeth. Natural Born Charmer. New York: William Morrow, 2007
5.     Roberts, Nora. Born in Fire. New York: Jove, 1996

Romantic Suspense
1.     Brockmann, Suzanne. Unsung Hero. New York: Ivy Books, 2000
2.     Brown, Sandra. Chill Factor. New York: Simon and Schuster, 2006
3.     Garwood, Julie Heartbreaker. New York: Pocket Books, 2001
4.     Lowell, Elizabeth. Always Time to Die. New York: William Morrow, 2005
5.     Stewart, Mary My Brother Michael. New York: Morrow, 2001

Paranormal
1.     Feehan, Christine. Dark Prince. New York: Dorchester Leisure Books, 2005
2.     Krentz, Jayne Ann. White Lies. New York: G. R Putnam's Sons, 2007
3.     Owens, Robin D. HeartMate. New York: Berkley, 2006.
4.     Sinclair, Linnea. Gabriel's Ghost. New York: Bantam, 2005
5.     Stuart, Anne. Cinderman. New York: Harlequin, 1994

I have read eighteen of the twenty-five titles; that’s 72%, not a very impressive score. Certainly if I were making such a list, my choices would be different. I’d add a Mary Balogh title to the trad Regency list for starters. Not only did she write an impressive number but she also introduced a level of sensuality that was rare in the genre at that time. And how can Loretta Chase’s Lord of Scoundrels be omitted from the Historicals? The Contemporary list (the only list that I have read in its entirety) seems weighted toward lighter fare. I’d add a Kathleen Gilles Seidel or a Deborah Smith or Robyn Carr title to give it more balance. I’d also balance the 21st-century titles with more 20th-century titles, particularly since the reissue of many books in electronic format means that once OOP books are now available.

So what do you think of this list of classics? How many have you read? What changes would you make to the list? What books published in the last five years have the enduring value that will make them classics? And do you think a book first published in 1994 belongs on a best-of-2012 list?


Note: An earlier version of this post appeared on The Romance Vagabonds blog in June 2008.

Citation for the article: Wyatt, Neal, Georgine Olson, Kristin Ramsdell, Joyce Saricks, and Lynne Welch. "Core Collections in Genre Studies: Romance Fiction 101." Reference & User Services Quarterly 47.2 (Winter 2007): 120(7). 

Thursday, October 27, 2011

Happy Christmas Read 5: Marian's Christmas Wish


Marian's Christmas Wish

By Carla Kelly

Publisher: Cedar Fort

Release Date: September 8, 2011

(Reissue of 1989 Signet Regency Romance)

4.5 Stars







The Wynswich family’s official year of mourning for Sir Bertram is drawing to a close as Christmas approaches, and Marian Wynswich knows that it may be her family’s last Christmas at Covenden Hall. She’s determined to make it the most joyous Christmas possible. But her older brother Percy is filled with despair over the debts his father has left, her younger brother Alistair has been expelled from Eton, and Ariadne, her beautiful older sister, is about to be betrothed to the toad of a suitor Percy has brought home, breaking Ari’s heart and the heart of the young vicar with whom she is in love.


Percy has brought another guest as well, Gilbert Collinwood, Earl of Ingraham, a seasoned diplomat. Ingraham is charmed by the artless Marian who reads Greek, plays chess, and cares for injured animals with a salve she has made, the same salve she is soon applying to the vicious burn on his cheek. Gil finds himself involved in madcap schemes, singing Christmas carols with a tuneless choir, and resolving Wynswich problems to keep Marian happy. Christmas wishes come true in unexpected ways before Marian realizes that her happiness rests with a certain earl.


Like all of Carla Kelly’s romances, this one is filled with characters who come alive for the reader. Marian is young, not yet seventeen, with a candor that makes her seem even younger at times. But she has intelligence, a loving heart, and an irrepressible sense of humor. Gil is a wonderful hero—understanding, great-hearted, and surprisingly unlordly for so high ranking an aristocrat—and with all the appeal of a man who combines tenderness with an understated charm. Despite the differences in age and fortune, I can imagine these two growing old together, celebrating Christmas through the years.


The Wynswich family is a delight as well. Each member emerges as vividly distinct, and their love for one another burns as brightly as a Christmas star. Even minor characters such as the pompous suitor and the mail coachman who befriends Marian are memorable. Only the villains are one-dimensional, and their appearance in the closing chapters comes as something of a shock. It changes the tone of the book, and I found the change disconcerting. But that’s a single flaw in a book that made me laugh, warmed my heart, and left me humming Christmas carols.  



Marian’s Christmas Wish is not a new Christmas book strictly speaking. It was first published in 1989, but it has been reissued as both in print and as an ebook for the 2011 Christmas season. Some of Kelly’s Christmas stories are also available. When I recommend Christmas reads, Carla Kelly is always high on my list. If you’ve never read a Carla Kelly book, Christmas is a great time to give yourself the gift of some of the best Regency romance ever. As for me, I’m counting the days--19-- until her collection of new Christmas stories is released.


What is your favorite traditional Regency Christmas romance?

Wednesday, September 1, 2010

Ten Under-read Romance Novels: Part II


























Just to refresh your memory, these five books, like those I blogged about last week, are novels that get less attention than others by the author or are the work of an author who gets less attention than her books merit. They offer the reader so much that I find it difficult to understand why more people don’t read these books and rave about them.



The Quiet Gentleman, Georgette Heyer (HQN, 2009--not edition shown above)

This tale of Gervase Frant, Earl St. Erth, and his return to Stanyon Castle and the relatives who had counted on his not surviving the war rarely shows up on lists of favorite Heyer novels. It’s certainly different from other Heyer romances. St. Erth is a far remove from arrogant, aristocratic heroes, and Drusilla Morville, a practical young woman with no claim to beauty and the disadvantage of a novel-writing mother who is a follower of Wollstonecraft and a democratic father who is a crony of Southey and Coleridge. The confident aristocrat and the innocent beauty do appear in the novel, but they are relegated to secondary roles. But readers who venture beyond the usual Heyer favorites will find in this novel some of the author’s most trenchant observation of Regency society and a heroine whose conversation is a delight. See the example below.


"Why, yes! It aches like the very deuce, but not, I assure you, as much as does my self-esteem! How came I to fall, like the rawest of greenhorns?" He received no answer to this, and added, with an effort at playfulness: "But I forget my manners! I must thank you for preserving my life, Miss Morville - even though it may have been at the cost of my cravat!"


"I am not, in general," said Miss Morville carefully, "an advocate for the employment of hyperbole in describing trifling services, but I believe, my lord, that in this instance I may be justly said to have done so."



Reforming Lord Ragsdale, Carla Kelly (Signet, 1995)

Carla Kelly is an under-read writer. I don’t understand why every book she writes isn’t on the best seller lists. Her most recent books, a Harlequin Historicals trilogy (Marrying the Captain, The Surgeon’s Lady, and Marrying the Royal Marine) joined the more than a dozen Kelly keepers already on my book shelves. Most of her novellas are there as well. But Reforming Lord Ragsdale is my favorite Kelly novel. First it pairs a self-destructive English aristocrat with an Irish indentured servant. Both characters are grieving losses they cannot speak of, but one of the book’s strengths is its wit and humor. Another strength is the friendship that develops between this unlikely pair as they save one another and as the hero grows to be the man he was meant to become. The first time I read the book I knew it was a romance and that the HEA was a given, but even knowing this, I couldn’t see how Kelly was going to allow the lord and the servant to remain together without pulling off some most un-Kelly trick. She doesn’t. They do. I love it!




Prospect Street, Emilie Richards (Mira, 2002)

Emilie Richards is one of those writers that I have followed through several genres and enjoyed every part of the journey. I started reading her books when she was writing categories, and her Men of Midnight trilogy and The Trouble with Joe are still among my keepers. I’ve read all her single-titles from Iron Lace (1996) through Fortunate Harbor (2010), including her Shenandoah Album books and her Ministry is Murder mysteries. But Prospect Street is the one I return to again and again. Faith Bronson leads a privileged life as the daughter of a Senator, the wife of a conservative lobbyist, and the mother of a son and a daughter. One evening she sets out to surprise her husband at their cabin and finds him in the arms of his male lover, a journalist. Her private discovery is followed by a media frenzy that insures her husband loses his job with Promise the Children, the organization he works for. Not only is Faith’s marriage disintegrating, but suddenly money is also a major concern. She finds sanctuary in a house on Prospect Street, a fixer-upper that has been in her mother’s family for generations. Prospect Street is the story of Faith’s journey to redefine herself and her relationships with her parents, her former husband, her children, the new man in her life, and the house on Prospect Street and the secrets it holds. Richards doesn’t vilify David Bronson, and she doesn’t turn Faith Bronson into a saint. He is the product of a conservative Christian upbringing and has spent his life denying his sexual preference. She is filled with anger and resentment over the shambles of her life. Their children are confused and troubled; the daughter Remy particularly is transformed by the destruction of the life she has known, changing from good girl to bitter, rebellious teen who refuses to see her father and constantly challenges her mother. Richards does not use her novel to sell a political or religious (or anti-religious) message. She presents complex characters with messy lives who struggle to forgive and to grow. The ending may be a bit too easy for all this complexity, but the book is a fascinating, human story.



In the Midnight Rain, Ruth Wind (HarperTorch 2000)

Whether she’s writing as Barbara Samuel, Barbara O’Neal, or Ruth Wind, this writer creates stories that engage me intellectually and emotionally. She also has a gift for creating places so detailed and richly textured that I finish her books feeling as if I’ve smelled the flowers and felt the breezes that ruffle the trees. Pine Bend, Texas, the setting of In the Midnight Rain is a place I know by heart after half a dozen readings of this book since its publication in 2000. Ellie Connor, the heroine, is a writer whose specialty is biographies of musicians. She comes to Pine Bend to research her next subject, Mabel Beauvais, a gorgeous and talented blues singer who mysteriously disappeared just as she was on the cusp of stardom. Ellie is also searching for her father; the only thing she knows about him is that a post card from her mother links him to this East Texas town. Via the Internet, Ellie becomes friendly with Dr. Laurence “Blue” Reynard, a handsome, wealthy widower, who offers Ellie and April, her dog, a place to stay while she is in Pine Bend. Blue is a needy soul whose love of music is as deep as Ellie’s, and despite his reputation as a heartbreaker, Ellie finds him irresistible. Ellie and Blue’s love story is interwoven with the double mystery and connected to the lives of a large and fascinating cast of secondary characters—black and white. These characters, major and minor, are flawed adults who inhabit a place entangled in history, personal and public. Racism is part of the world Wind shows readers, but so are the solid friendships that exist across racial lines. This is a novel as filled with difficult truths and emotional power as the blues beloved by the characters. And, unlike some of the under-read books I’ve blogged about that are hard to find, In the Midnight Rain is now available as an ebook.
























Venus in Blue Jeans, Meg Benjamin (Samhain, 2009)

This novel, coincidentally another Texas book, is different from the other books in this two-part blog. I’ve only read it twice, and those readings were both recent. I might have missed it if not for my friends and former Romance Vagabond companions, Lindsey (Managing Editor for Samhain), who sent me a copy, and Manda, whose rave first alerted me to the book. I immediately fell in love with Konigsburg, a small town that is not idyllic but rather filled with the kind of characters a reader can believe in. Docia Kent, bookstore owner, and Cal Toleffson, veterinarian, are relative newcomers to the town and still learning its quirks and customs. Their status offer a point of view that is different from the more common small-town heroine/hero who is either championing the hometown or in conflict with it. Another thing that set VIBJ apart from many contemporary romances is that while the attraction between Docia and Cal is instantaneous, a relationship develops between them before they fall into bed. The reader has time to find the characters likeable and to find their liking for one another as credible as their lust for one another. Their story is funny and sweet and sexy—a combination I favor, and the secondary characters are individual and interesting. Not many authors enter my autobuy list on the strength of one book. Meg Benjamin did. And Venus in Blue Jeans is just the first book in a four-book series that also includes Wedding Bell Blues, Be My Baby, and Long Time Gone.


What under-read books do you recommend I try? Do you have an autobuy list? What makes an author an autobuy for you?